About Resilience and Peas


(In ‘The Scotsman’ on Saturday 7th July)

When I was fifteen, I got my first job, working as a waiter in the (now defunct) Forth Bridges Motel, a very ugly concrete building that jutted out over the river at South Queensferry. During most of the summer holidays of 1972, I worked 46 hours a week, often doing two shifts in a day and cycling back and forward from  Queensferry to Kirkliston, where I lived, though I confess that often my dad, who had encouraged this enterprise, came and picked me and the bike up after the last plate was put in the dishwasher. I cleared up after breakfast in this fairly fancy four star joint, and set up for lunch which I duly served. I was very small for my age, and the waiter’s jacket was too big and I was, I freely admit it, cute, with a slightly Oliver Twistish…twist.The ladies who lunched there gave me piles of change and often I went home with pocketsful which was handy because I was only earning £11 a week. My mother, not a lady who spent freely, was so pleased that I was doing something productive with my summer, that she provided the extra cash necessary for me to buy my first stereo, then, most probably for her own sake, added some headphones.

Among the staff, ruled over by a Head Waiter with the entirely inaccurate name of Goodfellow, was Arthur, a wide boy from Glasgow not much older than me; Colleen, a kind older woman who looked after the kids in the team and Richard, who was the first gay person I knew. He was a student and was considered an intellectual; I remember him saying that coq au vin was a dish that contained his two favourite things. I didn’t fully understand the attendant hilarity. The chef, an enormous Swiss man, was a terrifying misogynistic lump who swore endlessly and creatively and who bullied the young pastry chef, Stewart, who, if I was working late in the afternoon when his boss had gone, fed me trifles from the ‘Taste of Scotland’ menu. 46 years on, I remember the trifles.

In later years I worked as a shop assistant and (unbelievably) as a security guard at a whisky bond, this latter a help of sorts when I began teaching, since the boss had told me on the first day that ‘if anyone broke in’ I should run away, find a phone box and call the police. There are many, many stories about the shop and the bond, but I never have forgotten these formative weeks working as a waiter, learning where to put the cutlery, learning which wine went in which glass and learning what to do if, as I did once, you accidentally serve some peas (buttered and minted) into the back of a bride’s veil (the answer to this is…nothing, just walk away, shortly she will be delirious with drink).

So yes, it was about earning, but it was also about learning. In today’s Scotland, we are, it seems, destined to call our young people ‘learners’  – a move which happened just after I had started calling them ‘students’ rather than ‘pupils’; in my career I have always been well behind the curve of jargon, a fact of which I am sincerely proud. Anyway, these ‘learners’ have a great many qualities – I believe young Scots today to be more skilled, more confident, more emotionally intelligent and generally more socially adept than their parents or grandparents were when they were young. I think they are generally kinder. However, they lack knowledge (I save this precious morsel for another day) and, my sainted aunt, they lack resilience – they are ill more often than their great-grandmothers; they fall apart if a friend says something inopportune; they do not sleep; they get driven everywhereby their parents lest they are abducted and sold into slavery; they are fragile to a fault.

Schools have responded to this of course, often in commendable ways. They organise courses in ‘resilience training’ or – in the case of one famous school – ‘grit’. Outdoor learning, and its partner, outdoor education contribute to this and there is no doubt that hanging by your fingernails from the Old Man of Hoy may make you see last night’s Snapchat insult in a more measured light. But along with all the other extras crammed on to the Scottish curriculum in recent years, are these things enough to arrest this particular malaise? Parents moan about their children’s inability to do practical things by themselves but very often won’t let them touch the cooker or take the bus into town until they’re 23.

I suggest work. In the workplace, you have to be on time; you have to dress correctly; if you miss a shift you won’t get paid; your boss will complain if you are idle or incompetent. However, most importantly, people treat you as an adult and they respect you for what you do, if you do it well. They support you practically and with banter; they help you grow up. Your parents and teachers aren’t there and you have to get on with it. So, I advocate a new move that encourages young people to work and thus develop resilience through the challenges of the workplace. I loved my schooldays, but Colleen and Arthur and Richard and even old Goodfellow taught me too and I thank them for these lessons. Come on young ‘uns, earn while you learn!



  1. Cameron, Enjoyed your piece – and congratulations on getting your “coq au vin” joke past the subs (not that the Scotsman HAS subs, these days…)  I certainly agree, as someone who started full-time work as a 17-year-old in 1972 on a nominal 12 pounds a week, on how much one can learn from first encountering the world of work. (Nominal because bogus “expenses” inflated my take-home pay to closer to 15 pounds.) But I’m not sure most young uns need to be urged to earn while they learn. I’m told a significant proportion of university students now have part-time jobs through out the term – not just in the summer holidays, as we practically all did.  I’m sure the most prosperous students don’t have to do that, but the fact that so many do surely diminishes what they can get out of university – and reflects the inequality of opportunity in the wider society. Look forward to seeing youse on the 28th. Andrew


  2. Couldn’t agree more with you, although student jobs and holiday jobs seem increasingly hard to come by. My eldest daughter applied for more than 40 jobs in retail or catering during her 2nd year at Glasgow University and was turned down on the basis of “lack of experience”.
    She has worked as a kids club leader, office junior and “fryer” in the past but this was not enough.
    I did at one point suggest that she do what one of my school friends did when we both went for an interview for bar work which asked for experience … “I lied” said my friend who clearly got the job instead of her honest chum!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s